Author; Kazuo Ishiguro
Introduction1. This book works at three levels
A. A Story about some kids growing up, their lives, loves, emotional entanglements, etc.
B. A sort of science fiction story about an ethically challenged society in which cloning occurs to create organ donors. Gets into ethics of cloning, of transplantation, of person being a means to an end.
C. A philosophic and social enquiry. eg Philosophic; “what is a life? what is a soul? Can a clone have a soul?. eg Social; eg how being “Pawns in a game” is the way things happen in the world. Other issues; mortality, memory
Ethical issues in the novel
1. Justice, fairness
2. Autonomy; are organ donors ever in a position to give consent?
(a) Issue of coercion
(b) Using persons as means to an end
For any organ donor, normally do have ability to consent. Consider someone contemplating donating to a relative. Issue of beneficence (help them) vs. individual autonomy. Is there really such a thing as fully informed consent?
Kant; 2nd categorical imperative. Do not use anyone as a means to an end. All persons must be treated as ends in themselves.
Ethics of Transplants
(A) Recipients of organs; Issues of Distributive Justice;
How do we choose recipients when there are a limited number of organs? Various criteria have been suggested or used. Why should these be used or not used? In the early days of chronic dialysis; God squads were set up at hospitals (eg Seattle) to determine who would be given a slot. Often social worth, mental health, family connections, support systems, age, used by these panels
Criteria
1. Age?
2. Social worth?
3. Money; whoever can pay for it
4. Individual merit, including education
5. Family status;
6. Lottery. Used in case of limited drugs available for Multiple Sclerosis
7. Clinical criteria
Three examples of likely abuse
1. Mickey Mantle; baseball player; He had terminal cancer with liver cirrhosis. Received a liver transplant 1-2 months before his death. Why? Money? Position?
2. Governor Casey of Pennsylvania; had amyloidosis; received two organs; went right to head of the line. Why? Social worth, position.
3. Deciding based on cause of organ failure. Livers given preferentially to those who got liver disease from hepatitis rather than cirrhosis. If have two persons and one liver, and one got their liver disease as result of hepatitis, other from alcohol abuse; Should preference for liver be given to those whose liver disease is result of hepatitis?
------------------------------------------------------------- Done re editing
Ethics re
Donors of organs
Autonomy For live donors, fully informed consent is mandatory; Hailsham is extreme example
Should consent be required if donor is dead? Or only for live donors?
For the dead donor, important to maintain respect for the dead and for their families. Cultures differ in their attitudes toward death.
Beneficence. All donors help someone. There is a trade-off.
Donor autonomy vs. recipient beneficence.
Our society gives preference to autonomy. But how far are we from a society that emphasizes beneficence?
Utilitarian ethics; greatest good for the greatest number; add up the benefits and the burdens. Problem here is that pure utility might be able to justify slavery, or even Hailsham. Will discriminate against the disabled. Why use resources to help those who are not contributing to society?
This book explores the very essence of ethics. What are the ethical obligations that we live under? In this book, children are taught their :duty. Lets look at duty.
Subject of Duty
In ethics, two types of ethical systems; (not always compatible)
Utiltarian; greatest good for the greatest number;; might justivy events in this book
Deontologic; moral obligation or duty to do certain things. Intent is what matters, not results.
Golden Rule
The Golden Rule is an ethical code that states one has a right to just treatment, and a responsibility to ensure justice for others. It is also called the ethic of reciprocity. It is arguably the most essential basis for the modern concept of human rights, A key element of the golden rule is that a person attempting to live by this rule treats all people, not just members of his or her in-group, with consideration.
Ancient Greece;
"One should never do wrong in return, nor mistreat any man, no matter how one has been mistreated by him." - Plato's Socrates (Crito, 49c
"What thou avoidest suffering thyself seek not to impose on others." – Epictetus[11]
Judaism;
Torah or Bible; Leviticus; "You shall not take vengeance or bear a grudge against your kinsfolk. Love your neighbor as yourself":.
The stranger who resides with you shall be to you as one of your citizens; you shall love him as yourself, for you were strangers in the land of Egypt: I the LORD am your God. ”
Talmud; Rabbi Hillel, asked to sum up the Torah while standing on one foot; " That which is hateful to you, do not do to your fellow. That is the whole Torah; the rest is commentary (the explanation); go and learn. [
Christianity; Jesus reported to have preached the Golden Rule
Immanuel Kant
The categorical imperative is the central philosophical concept in the moral philosophy of Immanuel Kant, as well as modern deontological ethics. Introduced in Kant's ("Groundwork for the Metaphysics of Morals"), it may be defined as the standard of rationality from which all moral requirements derive.
According to Kant, human beings occupy a special place in creation, and morality can be summed up in one ultimate commandment of reason, or imperative, from which all duties and obligations derive. He defined an imperative as any proposition that declares a certain action (or inaction) to be necessary. A hypothetical imperative compels action in a given circumstance: if I wish to quench my thirst, I must drink something. A categorical imperative, on the other hand, denotes an absolute, unconditional requirement that asserts its authority in all circumstances, both required and justified as an end in itself. It is best known in its first formulation:
"Act only according to that maxim whereby you can at the same time will that it should become a universal law."[1]
On this basis, Kant derives second formulation of the categorical imperative from the first.
• "Act in such a way that you treat humanity, whether in your own person or in the person of any other, always at the same time as an end and never merely as a means to an end."
John Rawls; Theory of Justice; Justice as fairness; Develped idea of orginal position.
The original position is a central feature of John Rawls's social contract account of justice, “justice as fairness,” It is designed to be a fair and impartial point of view that is to be adopted.
we are to imagine ourselves in the position of free and equal persons who jointly agree upon and commit themselves to principles of social and political justice. The main distinguishing feature of the original position is “the veil of ignorance”: to insure impartiality of judgment, the parties are deprived of all knowledge of their personal characteristics and social and historical circumstances. They do know of certain fundamental interests they all have, plus general facts about psychology, economics, biology, and other social and natural sciences. The parties in the original position are presented with a list of the main conceptions of justice drawn from the tradition of social and political philosophy, and are assigned the task of choosing from among these alternatives the conception of justice that best advances their interests in establishing conditions that enable them to effectively pursue their final ends and fundamental interests.
Rawls contends that the most rational choice for the parties in the original position are the two principles of justice
Need to carefully examine many of the political fads that have come along, and make sure that they are not substituting one immoral system for another.
3. P4. Paragraph 2. Note on language and ownership. “You try and do your best; you don’t have unlimited patience and energy”
Why use the 2nd person instead of just saying “I try to do my best” Prior to this had been using 1st person, then suddenly switches. Why?
A common device people use to avoid ownership of a thought they are not proud of. Kathy is not proud of what she is saying, so makes it impersonal
4. There are hints right from the first page that this is no ordinary story. Carer, donor, agitated vs. calm, recovery times, fewer and fewer donors left.
5. P6. Kathy says she realizes “how lucky we have been” Why lucky? Organ donors die young. How is this lucky?
6. There is much interaction between Kathy and Tommy in the initial part of the book (P 6-26). The interaction itself is like any ordinary interaction in any novel. What makes it different here is that we now know about the perverse background; this creates a disproportionate tension.
There are other ordinary interactions in the novel that also highlight the tensions, e.g. the hiding places of the children, the anger of the various teachers, etc.
7. Is there any indication that Kathy might be aware that their so-called “duty” might not be a “duty”?
A: Little things get slipped in about increased awareness of their future
B. Miss Lucy; “We are not taught enough about donations” “She seemed angry” These
things are slipped in artfully.
8. What is being done to these children is an atrocity, and it is huge. Most novels with a similar theme have some element of resistance. Why is there no resistance here? We don’t hear about any kids running away. They may try to bargain for more time before starting donations, but no one seems to give any thought to simply running away.
How realistic is this?
Kids brought up from an early age believing in concept of duty. No framework for believing this is anything out of the ordinary.
9. Discuss the concept of the “gallery”. Why does Madam take the best pictures made by the children for her collection (?gallery) We learn later it is to prove that these children have souls. This is an important feature of this fable. Do cloned beings have souls? Does anyone? Are we all just a bunch of chemicals?
10. What do you think of Madame’s reaction to the kids? She is apparently repulsed; like a fear of spiders (p32-36) “of how you were brought into this world and why”
11. Smoking; another example of foreshadowing. Of what is to come. Miss Lucy lectures kids about smoking “you are special; you need to be kept healthy”. No one is willing to question why this is so. Even at this early age (age 10), they have some inkling of what is to come.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
12. P 81. How did children first learn of donations? “Told and not told” Miss Lucy on P 81; she hears them plan a future, egg to go to America to be movie stars, and tells them what their lives will entail. They are 15 years old. Raised for one purpose; toe donate vital organs. But “we already knew that” We’d been “told and not told.”
Recollection of what Lucy said is different for each student (like Rashomon)
13. P83. Students gradually learn that their health (e.g. sexually transmitted diseases) are more important than they would be to students in the outside world. They also learn that they can’t have babies. Tension builds as the students learn of things that are dark compared to the bright lives at Hailsham.
14. Chapter 8, P90-100. Entire chapter is filled with obsessions about sex. Why does author do this? Shows that these kids are normal; also it is a way to deflect the more expected concern about donations.
15. Chapter 9. The plot thickens. Tommy tells Kathy about Miss Lucy’s talk with him, that his art does matter. Why does she tell him this? If his art is good, may prove he has a soul and ? might this spare him? We learn here that Miss Lucy has left Hailsham and won’t be returning. Tommy says that “it’s not like a game anymore …. We’ve got to think carefully
16, P 138-158; Norwood trip. Why was this so important; takes up over 20 pages. There is speculation that Hailsham students could get a deferral of becoming donors if they could prove they were in love. i.e. qualified. Love as a magic quality to delay death.
17. Hailsham is presented as if it were a private school in America, with bonding experiences for students, a sense of alma mater, etc.
18. P 256. Miss Emily comments that Tommy has a big heart, and that Kathy has done very well. Madame then says “What good has it done them?” Universal message here. What good does it do anyone to do well, to have a big heart, when what awaits is death, suffering, etc.
19. P 258. Hailsham is referred to as “a shining beacon, an example of how we might move to a more humane and better way of doing things” . What is wrong with this statement? Confuses morality of means and ends. If the end is rotten, don’t make it OK by a humane means.
20 These two women (Miss Emily and Madame) were reformers within a larger movement, that of using clones for transplants. They wanted to reform the system when nothing less than getting rid of the system would be right. Eg There is no such thing as a humane system of slavery. If one puts in better treatment of slaves, they are still slaves.
21. P266. Students were “pawns in a game” “Sometimes that’s how things happen in this world” This is a statement that pertains to the universal themes explored in this book.
Q. We all know that mortality cannot be avoided. It is not negotiable. So how is this fundamentally different here?
A. Ethical issue of dignity of individual. Person being used as means to someone elses end.
B. Mortality that is man made is somehow different than that which is part of a normal life progression. Murder is a crime. Capital punishment is a subject of much debate
C. Life is shorter
D. End of life is known, predictable.
Q. How did this system come about? Who oversees it?
Q. How far-fetched is this story? Could this happen here? Other atrocities in human experimentation, slavery, using humans as means to an end.
Q. Why do the graduates of these various schools continue to “do their duty”? Why don’t they simply run away? Who will stop them? This is never discussed in the book.
Showing posts with label Medical Humanities. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Medical Humanities. Show all posts
Saturday, December 5, 2009
Wednesday, December 2, 2009
Course 1; 2009; Fall; Book 2; Lost in America;
Author; Sherwin Nuland
There is a real sense of knowing this man through this book. He does not pull punches, fully exposes himself warts and all, and thus reveals his full humanity. The book also contains one of the best descriptions of depression in literature, and raises many questions about life events that may have contributed to that depression. It is an incredibly moving story.
Winner of the 2003 Kenneth Johnson Memorial Award for the best book on mental illness from the National Alliance for the Mentally Ill
Ethical Issues
1. Aging – Social Issues
2. Doctor Patient Relations; How is Meyer N treated in Clinic?
3. Rationing of Care; Limited for Elderly &/or Infirm?
4. Autonomy; Truth Telling; Telling diagnosis to patient
5. Managing Depression; major procedure (eg lobotomy) in someone with diminished competence.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------edit
General Issues
1. What did you like or not like about the book?
2. What issues did it raise for you personally?
3. Is this book Nulands way of fighting his way out of despair? Coming to terms with some of the causes of his depression?
4. Or did he write book to assuage his guilt regarding his wishes that his father would die and save him embarrassment?
5. Major issue is family dynamics and dysfunction. What do you think?
6. Other issues are raised; ethnicity, immigrants difficulties, guilt, personal failure, poverty, despair, hatred, rage, control.
7. What do you think it was like for Nuland to discover that his father had tertiarly syphilis?
8. What does this book tell us about memory? What does it mean that so many complex full lives are not only gone, but not even remembered? Standing in cemetery in forward; lives long-mourned or forgotten
9. Understanding life; Can we ever really understand ourselves? Is this really a journey that can’t be completed?
10. Making peace with our parents. This book is about Nulands attempt to make such a peace. Can we ever do this?
Close Reading
6. Read Depression; wonderful description here. Examine the words used on P 3-5.
7. “Return to memory”. P 4. Have any of you ever tried to do this? Difficult?
8. Re the psychiatric resident who refused to give in to the others. What do you think about him? Guardian angel? Fortunate interlocutor? Quirk of luck? What happens when we dont have such luck? How are lives changed? Path in the road. If Nuland had had lobotomy, might never have become great writer.
9. Role of hope. P 8. Nuland always knew he would get better. What is the impact of this optimism? How are love and connection eg with his children, related to this.
10. Meyer Nudelman; sui generis, in class by himself. Isnt that true for everyone?
11. Statement p 11. “A proud man reduced to deblitiy is hypersensitive to any perceived slight.” Agree?
12. Fathers anger (rage). Where does this fit in the spectrum of mental illness. It is a paramount feature of depression, more in men than women often coming as attacks.
13. P12 “His weakness was his strength” This statement seems to be a paradox. What does it mean?
14. P12; “Not freedom I should have been seeking but understanding”. (And what else? Perhaps acceptatnce that his father did the best he was capable of doing. The father was also depressed, and lacked the sophistication of the son not to take it out on his children.
15. P14-15 How are these feelings connected to Nulands depression?
16. P 18. What was the immigrant experience like? Tuberculosis was common disease of immigrants. No real treatement at that time. Disease, poverty, bigotry, harsh work conditions all part of immigrant experience, but still better than where they came from.
17. P 20. Why might father not speak of family back home? Desertion? Left agisnt their will? Did not want to feel responsible for them? Too responsible with too much sorrow?
18. P21. In telling story of his forbears changing their surname with no guilt, is Nuland trying to justify his doing this? Does he protest too much?
19. P22. Most families have secrets. What might have been going on here?
20. P23. What is reason for nostalgia of immigrant experience? Is it because it reminds us of our lost youth? The possibilities, most of which were never realized? A way to connect with forebears that we ignored when we were younger?
24. P37. Do we in fact repress hurtful memories? Nuland did not repress these; they are there. Is this why he got depressed?
25. What it the importance of children to an immigrant family? Triumph over adversity and hardships. Gives some sense of purpose to work and struggle. Children are the proof of value of perseverance. A form of redemption.
26. p 38. Why does Sherwin’s father get angry when his son pulls back from his clumsy gesture of affection?
Anger is not a primary emotion. Is always secondary to something else,
usually fear or hurt. In this case, primary emotion is hurt. Father is
frequently hurt. He is probably chronically depressed and thus easily hurt
and on edge or rage.
27. Read P 64-65; Yom Kippur prayer; a central feature of the day. Nuland attributes a major cause of his depression to be this prayer. (What do you think?) Prayer contains religious/supernatural forces. The imagery consumed him; he blelieved in this literally. Lingering fear, re the risk of luring him back to the depression, the obsessive thinking.
Could this really be the basis of depression?
Depression is result of complex interaction between genetics and environment. (nature vs nurture). This is the environment/nurture part.
28. Read P69. What was impact on Sherwin of hearing his family described as crazy?
29. Read P71 Discuss the differences between his father and his uncle Manny
30. Read P72-73; This says much about the nature of connection in many first generation immigrant families
31. Read P77 Shows the complexity of relationships; multiple facets.
32. P 79; Discuss influence of Esther; calm and cheerful; she changed the mood of the entire house.
33. Read P82-83 This is one of the best descriptions of grief in an 11 year old boy who has just lost his mother.
34. Read P 85-86 Discussion of mourning and grief. Each one alone; Private thoughts. Is this peculiar to this author, or is it universal? Intimacy and closeness are often cut off at times of intense grief
35. P 88-89 Two brothers showed a ‘remarkable sense of obligation. Why do some act this way, most do not?
36. P 90 It is Tante Aya who prevailed over his father in decision for him to spend time with Joe’s family. Women often strong figures in immigrant families. It was their role to hold family together, ensure enough financial stablitiy, etc.
37. P 92. Good description of poor boy being rescued by wealthy, and how that can be transforming. What are the pros and cons, if any, of him having that escape?
38. P 92 Joe sits in his fathers place. Place has great significance. I remember a very dominant man who always took a seat at the head of the table whenever he went anywhere.
39. P 92-99; Joe’s offer; A wonderful description of ambivalence when faced with a critical choice. Much anguish all around. Everyone has their own ambivalence to deal with. Discuss from point of view of Sherwin, his father, his Bubbe.
40. Read P 96-97 A description of the love that occurs in some close knit families that transcends the poverty, the superstition, the craziness. Children as consolation for all the trials of life.
41. P 98. Meyer explodes. How do you suppose he felt? Was he justified in wanting Sherwin to stay with him? In seeing it as an affront? What about Joe? What was he thinking? There is an expression “No good deed goes unpunished”. This was certainly true of Joe’s offer. Except that one could make the case that the offer was insensitive.
42. Read P 102 Good description of Rheumatic Fever; common in those days. Complication of Strep Throat. Wiped out since advent of penicillin. When I was a med student, no RF but much RHD. Now most cases have died. Then disease could cause heart valve closure or leakage, usually in 30s and 40s, followed by heart failure. One of commonest causes of heart failure in 1940s and 1950s. as legacy for earlier Strep throat.
43. P102 Words in medicine have powerful connotations to lay persons, especially to the unsophisticated. Words like murmur, cancer. Discuss.
44. P 104-105; Nuland compares RF treatment in early 1940s to modern concepts of treatment of RF caution against “unwarranted invalidism” Much of medicine has changed, relying on “evidence based” medicine, rather that what appeared to make sense but was nothing more than folklore. Harvey that Sherwin had known was “gone forever”
45. P 105. Meyer Nudelman speaks of thoughts of suicide if he got more bad news about Harvey. Do you think he might have killed himself? Was he being dramatic? Was Meyer that depressed? What was evidence, if any of depression ? Yes, his lack of sense of self-esteem, purposelessness, irritability, fits of rage, trouble connecting, all point to depression.
46. P107 Sherwin speaks of redemption for his father. This is a common theme in books, film, etc. It cuts across myths from many cultures. For all of Meyer’s troubles, he still saw Sherwin as the carrier of that redemption. Now much do we count on children to do this? Is there a flip side to this? Eg putting pressure on kids to fulfill our needs?
47. P 108; Sherwin speaks of self-incrimination later in life for not taking his father more seriously. Was this justified?
48. P109 Description of estrangement by means of how the sons refer to the father. How common is this for kids?
49. Read P 111 Very accurate description of clinic. A marked disparity between medical care for poor vs affluent. Discuss. What were differences? Affluent got appointments, seen on time, treated with dignity. Back then, Sherwin knew this was no way to treat patients. As he states, this is his model for how not to treat patients.
50. P 111. What is dignity? How important is it? What effect does it have on persons, like Meyer, who aren’t treated with dignity?
51. Episode in subway car when he explodes at three girls. What led up to this outburst? Underlying depression, loss of dignity with searing of soul, frustration, insensivity of strangers lead to rage which leads to public humiliation.
52. P 116 Description of a federal bureaucracy. This is why so many persons don’t want government running anything.
53. P 118-120. Sherwin continually refers to himself as being a 14 year old self-absorbed boy. Is he being too hard on himself? Is this normall? What about children who are self-sacrificing? Again, when they get to the movie and Sherwin refuses to go and his father pleads with him, the scene is heart-breaking. Sherwin states that “anyone with an iota of compassion would have responded”
54. P 120 Was Sherwins reaction justified? Point of view of 14 year old vs more experienced adult recpgnizing cruelty of his own behavior. Do we all do this?
55. P 120 Father asks Sherwin to show Rachmones; this is a major concept in Yiddish, for which there is no exact translation. He translates it as mercy, but its closest meaning is “compassion.” It is a concept that is central to Judaism. I have heard one scholar translate it as referring to the love that a mother has for her newborn baby.
56. P 121 Are painful memories likely to be repressed? I am not sure, perhaps we don’t allow ourselves to dwell on them because of the pain, and because this saves us from depression. Avoiding them allows apparent forgetting. The fact that so many of his memories are accessible likely has contributed to his depression.
57. Read P 123 Wonderful description of the retention of a powerful response to fathers displeasure. Father may have been weak and inadequate, but in this way he was exceedingly powerful. Sherwin cowered. “flaying the skin from my soul” Again, probably contributing factor is his depression.
58. P 125. Grandmother and aunt are described as holding onto grudges. Why do people hold onto grudges?
59. P 131-133; Issue of homosexuality vs feminine traits. High school boys tend to equate the two. Sherwin engages in self-deprecation. MMPI, the most widely used psychological inventory, historically made the assumption that the two were equal They tried to diagnose homosexuality by asking questions like “I would like a job as a flower arranger”, or “I like going to the ballet” T or F.
60. P133 Talks of his “constant introverted sadness”. This is the first evidence of his depression.
61. P 133-134 Aunt thought Sherwins depression was secondary to fathers tirade three weeks earlier. Was it? Yes and no. No because he has the genetic predisposition. Yes, because the tirade may have been a trigger.
62. Psychiatrist. Why is he so effective? Most important features are that he is gentle and “understanding” Without these, competence doesn’t mean much.
63. P 134. Why did the taking of a shower, and toweling vigorously work to get him out of depression? Placebo effect. Sherwin believed in the recommendations of the psych because he liked and trusted him. And it worked.
64. P 137-138. Immigrant Jewish families; most came from Pale of Russia. Thin sliver of Western Russia, that permitted (required) Jews to live there. Mainly Ukraine, Belarus, Lithuania, Eastern Poland. Romania. These were areas completely occupied by Nazi Germany, and it was a major trauma for families who had emigrated to hear about the murder of the families that they had left behind. The reaction of Meyer was repeated thousands of times for other immigrants from Eastern Europe.
65. Bubbeh and Rose came from same town. Why didn’t they react?
66. P 139 Meyer gets letter from his brother who left Russia 20-30 years after Meyer left. He did not know he was alive. This means that one member of his family survived Holocaust. Why didn’t Meyer write back to his brother?.
67. P 140 Why did Sherwin want name change? Embarrasment, ridicule, bigotry, medical school quotas, unpleasant associations
68. p 144. Sherwin and Harvey are changing name to Nuland. Father wants to change his name also. Why? He fears that he will be labeled as alien, different, left behind by his sons . “We should be all the same” His fears are accurate.
69. P 144-145 Why don’t the sons want their father to change his name? Their name change is as much an escape from father as it is the other reasons. Their major motivation for their own name change is shame
70. P 145 Sherwin makes the point that he is still Nudelman. He points out the fact that name change was illegal. This is a metaphor for the fact that he is still Nudleman in his heart and soul.
71. P 149 Public wards. Why are they no longer there? There was no privacy and they represented the absence of dignity. It was assembly line medicine. We would make rounds, going from bed to bed, intern, resident, attending staff, every morning. Meanwhile, paying patients had semi-private rooms (two per room), and really affluent had private (one person in room). The contrast based on ability to pay ended with the advent of universal health care and everyone being treated the same.
72. P 150 Father particularly proud that his son would be a doctor. Why was he proud? This was culmination of his life. It had all been worthwhile. All the suffering, death of son and wife, poverty, illness; finally his life could be said to have purpose.
73. P 151 Sherwin says that he did not want to work in laboratories, even thlough he liked science. “Biology with people” He was Bubbes son; life meant people. How do doctors choose their specialties? By their underlying personalities.
74. P 151. Sherwin has an idealized picture of what a doctor should be. Is this realistic? Yes, he has seen it. Important feature is to maintain hope. What are the two factors Sherwin thinks are most important? Two persons; Leo; imperturbability --> loss of panic and pessimism . Willie; energetic competence. These are his role models.
75. P 152. Sherwin thinks it naïve to link science with literature. Is this correct? I don’t think so. Many doctors are also great writers. Checkov, Michael Crichton, Somerset Maugham. In my opinion, appreciation of literature makes one a beltter doctor
76. P 153. Sherwin would leave whatever he was doing if he thought his father needed him. Is this self-sacrifice a good thing?. Open to many answers.
77. P 154. Father is chronically ill, but can go for years like this. Sherwin admits he wishes father would die. Is this wish bad? Irresponsible? Common under the circumstances?
78. Many become alienated from a sick parent, and do anything to escape, including changing name, religion, occupation, etc. Associate parent with oppression, superstition, bad upbringing, etc.
79. P 158. Camp Boiberik exemplities values of many immigrants, (not like Meyer). These were peope who had rejected religion and Zionism. Their faith was secular and political. Socialism or Communism, usuall with their own separate camps and instituions, One common denomator was commitment to Yiddish language.
80. P 159-161. At camp, 19 years old, entering senior year of college, he undergoes an “exploratory hedonism” What was that about? Major change from his previous life. “time of your life”
81. P 161-163 Sherwin is furious that his father wants him to come visit him in the hospital, even though he is getting better. Is fathers demand reasonable and responsible? Is Sherwins fury reasonable and responsible?
82. P 163 Sherwin has a recurrence of depression. Discuss. How is it manifest? loss of enthusiasm, loss of sense of pleasure, and irritability. Triggered by visit to father. Powerful trigger. His whole personality changes. This is a good description of what depression feels like “I lost the happy wonder”
83. P 164. Application to Med School I also came from a predom Jewish school; about 20 applied to Med School; 8 were accepted.
84. P 166 Why is he so eager to go to Yale? Fantasy, affluent America, free of Bronx, Yiddish accents, his father. Unattainable, therefore even more desirable.
85. P 167 Re Meyer and Rose’s reaction to him possibley going to Yale, he feels smothered by their love. How does that work?
86. P 169-171 Why did Meyer want to marry Rose?
87. P 173. Why is Sherwin depressed again? He is not only going to College, but leaving his father and aunt for the first time. Guilt, dramatic change in life circumstances, likely act as triggers.
88. P 176-178. What do you think about Sherwins reaction to learning that his father had tabes dorsalis, one of the forms of neurosyphilis? Does it change his attitude toward his father? He refers to “strong man robbed of his manhood” And in very dramatic fashion, he becomes aware of his own longing, of the mutual love that he and his father have for each other. And this knowledge (P 183) allows Sherwin to appreciate the “magnitude of his burden”.
89. P 182-183 Re father not knowing his diagnosis. One of the principles of bioethics is autonomy. This includes the right of everyone to make their own decisions, and that requires full disclosure by any physician of whatever is wrong with the patient. This runs counter to the principle of beneficence in which you do whatever is right for the patient. In the case of Meyer, he was not told his diagnosis. Most bioethicists would disagree with this. What do you think?
90. Treatment of syphilis. Prior to penicillin (about 1945), treatment was of little value. Used fever therapy in attempt to kill spirochetes (organisms that cause the disease). However, penicillin is very effective for primary syphilis, but has little or no effect on later tabes.
91. P 184. Talks about his father having lost. What is he referring to? He had given up fighting against his disease, finally accepting that his life was over, and he had two sons to show for it.
92. P 188-192. Sherwin’s first girl friend. Contrast her family with his family and effect that had on him, seeing a family where they all liked each other. Was this because the families were really different or because the individuals had no history of tragedy, depression, etc.
93. P 193-194 Sherwin realizes he will never totally separate from his father and home. Why Is this? Drenched in memories, Old emotional burden both a burden and a support.
94. P 197 Why did Sherwin pick surgery as a specialty? Influence of charismatic teacher, for him a combination of aesthetics and intellectual factors,
95. P 206-209 Sherwins final visit with his father. Finally they were at peace with each other. Why couldn’t Sherwin tell his father that he loved him?
96. Afterward; In what ways will Sherwin never be free of his father?
There is a real sense of knowing this man through this book. He does not pull punches, fully exposes himself warts and all, and thus reveals his full humanity. The book also contains one of the best descriptions of depression in literature, and raises many questions about life events that may have contributed to that depression. It is an incredibly moving story.
Winner of the 2003 Kenneth Johnson Memorial Award for the best book on mental illness from the National Alliance for the Mentally Ill
Ethical Issues
1. Aging – Social Issues
2. Doctor Patient Relations; How is Meyer N treated in Clinic?
3. Rationing of Care; Limited for Elderly &/or Infirm?
4. Autonomy; Truth Telling; Telling diagnosis to patient
5. Managing Depression; major procedure (eg lobotomy) in someone with diminished competence.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------edit
General Issues
1. What did you like or not like about the book?
2. What issues did it raise for you personally?
3. Is this book Nulands way of fighting his way out of despair? Coming to terms with some of the causes of his depression?
4. Or did he write book to assuage his guilt regarding his wishes that his father would die and save him embarrassment?
5. Major issue is family dynamics and dysfunction. What do you think?
6. Other issues are raised; ethnicity, immigrants difficulties, guilt, personal failure, poverty, despair, hatred, rage, control.
7. What do you think it was like for Nuland to discover that his father had tertiarly syphilis?
8. What does this book tell us about memory? What does it mean that so many complex full lives are not only gone, but not even remembered? Standing in cemetery in forward; lives long-mourned or forgotten
9. Understanding life; Can we ever really understand ourselves? Is this really a journey that can’t be completed?
10. Making peace with our parents. This book is about Nulands attempt to make such a peace. Can we ever do this?
Close Reading
6. Read Depression; wonderful description here. Examine the words used on P 3-5.
7. “Return to memory”. P 4. Have any of you ever tried to do this? Difficult?
8. Re the psychiatric resident who refused to give in to the others. What do you think about him? Guardian angel? Fortunate interlocutor? Quirk of luck? What happens when we dont have such luck? How are lives changed? Path in the road. If Nuland had had lobotomy, might never have become great writer.
9. Role of hope. P 8. Nuland always knew he would get better. What is the impact of this optimism? How are love and connection eg with his children, related to this.
10. Meyer Nudelman; sui generis, in class by himself. Isnt that true for everyone?
11. Statement p 11. “A proud man reduced to deblitiy is hypersensitive to any perceived slight.” Agree?
12. Fathers anger (rage). Where does this fit in the spectrum of mental illness. It is a paramount feature of depression, more in men than women often coming as attacks.
13. P12 “His weakness was his strength” This statement seems to be a paradox. What does it mean?
14. P12; “Not freedom I should have been seeking but understanding”. (And what else? Perhaps acceptatnce that his father did the best he was capable of doing. The father was also depressed, and lacked the sophistication of the son not to take it out on his children.
15. P14-15 How are these feelings connected to Nulands depression?
16. P 18. What was the immigrant experience like? Tuberculosis was common disease of immigrants. No real treatement at that time. Disease, poverty, bigotry, harsh work conditions all part of immigrant experience, but still better than where they came from.
17. P 20. Why might father not speak of family back home? Desertion? Left agisnt their will? Did not want to feel responsible for them? Too responsible with too much sorrow?
18. P21. In telling story of his forbears changing their surname with no guilt, is Nuland trying to justify his doing this? Does he protest too much?
19. P22. Most families have secrets. What might have been going on here?
20. P23. What is reason for nostalgia of immigrant experience? Is it because it reminds us of our lost youth? The possibilities, most of which were never realized? A way to connect with forebears that we ignored when we were younger?
24. P37. Do we in fact repress hurtful memories? Nuland did not repress these; they are there. Is this why he got depressed?
25. What it the importance of children to an immigrant family? Triumph over adversity and hardships. Gives some sense of purpose to work and struggle. Children are the proof of value of perseverance. A form of redemption.
26. p 38. Why does Sherwin’s father get angry when his son pulls back from his clumsy gesture of affection?
Anger is not a primary emotion. Is always secondary to something else,
usually fear or hurt. In this case, primary emotion is hurt. Father is
frequently hurt. He is probably chronically depressed and thus easily hurt
and on edge or rage.
27. Read P 64-65; Yom Kippur prayer; a central feature of the day. Nuland attributes a major cause of his depression to be this prayer. (What do you think?) Prayer contains religious/supernatural forces. The imagery consumed him; he blelieved in this literally. Lingering fear, re the risk of luring him back to the depression, the obsessive thinking.
Could this really be the basis of depression?
Depression is result of complex interaction between genetics and environment. (nature vs nurture). This is the environment/nurture part.
28. Read P69. What was impact on Sherwin of hearing his family described as crazy?
29. Read P71 Discuss the differences between his father and his uncle Manny
30. Read P72-73; This says much about the nature of connection in many first generation immigrant families
31. Read P77 Shows the complexity of relationships; multiple facets.
32. P 79; Discuss influence of Esther; calm and cheerful; she changed the mood of the entire house.
33. Read P82-83 This is one of the best descriptions of grief in an 11 year old boy who has just lost his mother.
34. Read P 85-86 Discussion of mourning and grief. Each one alone; Private thoughts. Is this peculiar to this author, or is it universal? Intimacy and closeness are often cut off at times of intense grief
35. P 88-89 Two brothers showed a ‘remarkable sense of obligation. Why do some act this way, most do not?
36. P 90 It is Tante Aya who prevailed over his father in decision for him to spend time with Joe’s family. Women often strong figures in immigrant families. It was their role to hold family together, ensure enough financial stablitiy, etc.
37. P 92. Good description of poor boy being rescued by wealthy, and how that can be transforming. What are the pros and cons, if any, of him having that escape?
38. P 92 Joe sits in his fathers place. Place has great significance. I remember a very dominant man who always took a seat at the head of the table whenever he went anywhere.
39. P 92-99; Joe’s offer; A wonderful description of ambivalence when faced with a critical choice. Much anguish all around. Everyone has their own ambivalence to deal with. Discuss from point of view of Sherwin, his father, his Bubbe.
40. Read P 96-97 A description of the love that occurs in some close knit families that transcends the poverty, the superstition, the craziness. Children as consolation for all the trials of life.
41. P 98. Meyer explodes. How do you suppose he felt? Was he justified in wanting Sherwin to stay with him? In seeing it as an affront? What about Joe? What was he thinking? There is an expression “No good deed goes unpunished”. This was certainly true of Joe’s offer. Except that one could make the case that the offer was insensitive.
42. Read P 102 Good description of Rheumatic Fever; common in those days. Complication of Strep Throat. Wiped out since advent of penicillin. When I was a med student, no RF but much RHD. Now most cases have died. Then disease could cause heart valve closure or leakage, usually in 30s and 40s, followed by heart failure. One of commonest causes of heart failure in 1940s and 1950s. as legacy for earlier Strep throat.
43. P102 Words in medicine have powerful connotations to lay persons, especially to the unsophisticated. Words like murmur, cancer. Discuss.
44. P 104-105; Nuland compares RF treatment in early 1940s to modern concepts of treatment of RF caution against “unwarranted invalidism” Much of medicine has changed, relying on “evidence based” medicine, rather that what appeared to make sense but was nothing more than folklore. Harvey that Sherwin had known was “gone forever”
45. P 105. Meyer Nudelman speaks of thoughts of suicide if he got more bad news about Harvey. Do you think he might have killed himself? Was he being dramatic? Was Meyer that depressed? What was evidence, if any of depression ? Yes, his lack of sense of self-esteem, purposelessness, irritability, fits of rage, trouble connecting, all point to depression.
46. P107 Sherwin speaks of redemption for his father. This is a common theme in books, film, etc. It cuts across myths from many cultures. For all of Meyer’s troubles, he still saw Sherwin as the carrier of that redemption. Now much do we count on children to do this? Is there a flip side to this? Eg putting pressure on kids to fulfill our needs?
47. P 108; Sherwin speaks of self-incrimination later in life for not taking his father more seriously. Was this justified?
48. P109 Description of estrangement by means of how the sons refer to the father. How common is this for kids?
49. Read P 111 Very accurate description of clinic. A marked disparity between medical care for poor vs affluent. Discuss. What were differences? Affluent got appointments, seen on time, treated with dignity. Back then, Sherwin knew this was no way to treat patients. As he states, this is his model for how not to treat patients.
50. P 111. What is dignity? How important is it? What effect does it have on persons, like Meyer, who aren’t treated with dignity?
51. Episode in subway car when he explodes at three girls. What led up to this outburst? Underlying depression, loss of dignity with searing of soul, frustration, insensivity of strangers lead to rage which leads to public humiliation.
52. P 116 Description of a federal bureaucracy. This is why so many persons don’t want government running anything.
53. P 118-120. Sherwin continually refers to himself as being a 14 year old self-absorbed boy. Is he being too hard on himself? Is this normall? What about children who are self-sacrificing? Again, when they get to the movie and Sherwin refuses to go and his father pleads with him, the scene is heart-breaking. Sherwin states that “anyone with an iota of compassion would have responded”
54. P 120 Was Sherwins reaction justified? Point of view of 14 year old vs more experienced adult recpgnizing cruelty of his own behavior. Do we all do this?
55. P 120 Father asks Sherwin to show Rachmones; this is a major concept in Yiddish, for which there is no exact translation. He translates it as mercy, but its closest meaning is “compassion.” It is a concept that is central to Judaism. I have heard one scholar translate it as referring to the love that a mother has for her newborn baby.
56. P 121 Are painful memories likely to be repressed? I am not sure, perhaps we don’t allow ourselves to dwell on them because of the pain, and because this saves us from depression. Avoiding them allows apparent forgetting. The fact that so many of his memories are accessible likely has contributed to his depression.
57. Read P 123 Wonderful description of the retention of a powerful response to fathers displeasure. Father may have been weak and inadequate, but in this way he was exceedingly powerful. Sherwin cowered. “flaying the skin from my soul” Again, probably contributing factor is his depression.
58. P 125. Grandmother and aunt are described as holding onto grudges. Why do people hold onto grudges?
59. P 131-133; Issue of homosexuality vs feminine traits. High school boys tend to equate the two. Sherwin engages in self-deprecation. MMPI, the most widely used psychological inventory, historically made the assumption that the two were equal They tried to diagnose homosexuality by asking questions like “I would like a job as a flower arranger”, or “I like going to the ballet” T or F.
60. P133 Talks of his “constant introverted sadness”. This is the first evidence of his depression.
61. P 133-134 Aunt thought Sherwins depression was secondary to fathers tirade three weeks earlier. Was it? Yes and no. No because he has the genetic predisposition. Yes, because the tirade may have been a trigger.
62. Psychiatrist. Why is he so effective? Most important features are that he is gentle and “understanding” Without these, competence doesn’t mean much.
63. P 134. Why did the taking of a shower, and toweling vigorously work to get him out of depression? Placebo effect. Sherwin believed in the recommendations of the psych because he liked and trusted him. And it worked.
64. P 137-138. Immigrant Jewish families; most came from Pale of Russia. Thin sliver of Western Russia, that permitted (required) Jews to live there. Mainly Ukraine, Belarus, Lithuania, Eastern Poland. Romania. These were areas completely occupied by Nazi Germany, and it was a major trauma for families who had emigrated to hear about the murder of the families that they had left behind. The reaction of Meyer was repeated thousands of times for other immigrants from Eastern Europe.
65. Bubbeh and Rose came from same town. Why didn’t they react?
66. P 139 Meyer gets letter from his brother who left Russia 20-30 years after Meyer left. He did not know he was alive. This means that one member of his family survived Holocaust. Why didn’t Meyer write back to his brother?.
67. P 140 Why did Sherwin want name change? Embarrasment, ridicule, bigotry, medical school quotas, unpleasant associations
68. p 144. Sherwin and Harvey are changing name to Nuland. Father wants to change his name also. Why? He fears that he will be labeled as alien, different, left behind by his sons . “We should be all the same” His fears are accurate.
69. P 144-145 Why don’t the sons want their father to change his name? Their name change is as much an escape from father as it is the other reasons. Their major motivation for their own name change is shame
70. P 145 Sherwin makes the point that he is still Nudelman. He points out the fact that name change was illegal. This is a metaphor for the fact that he is still Nudleman in his heart and soul.
71. P 149 Public wards. Why are they no longer there? There was no privacy and they represented the absence of dignity. It was assembly line medicine. We would make rounds, going from bed to bed, intern, resident, attending staff, every morning. Meanwhile, paying patients had semi-private rooms (two per room), and really affluent had private (one person in room). The contrast based on ability to pay ended with the advent of universal health care and everyone being treated the same.
72. P 150 Father particularly proud that his son would be a doctor. Why was he proud? This was culmination of his life. It had all been worthwhile. All the suffering, death of son and wife, poverty, illness; finally his life could be said to have purpose.
73. P 151 Sherwin says that he did not want to work in laboratories, even thlough he liked science. “Biology with people” He was Bubbes son; life meant people. How do doctors choose their specialties? By their underlying personalities.
74. P 151. Sherwin has an idealized picture of what a doctor should be. Is this realistic? Yes, he has seen it. Important feature is to maintain hope. What are the two factors Sherwin thinks are most important? Two persons; Leo; imperturbability --> loss of panic and pessimism . Willie; energetic competence. These are his role models.
75. P 152. Sherwin thinks it naïve to link science with literature. Is this correct? I don’t think so. Many doctors are also great writers. Checkov, Michael Crichton, Somerset Maugham. In my opinion, appreciation of literature makes one a beltter doctor
76. P 153. Sherwin would leave whatever he was doing if he thought his father needed him. Is this self-sacrifice a good thing?. Open to many answers.
77. P 154. Father is chronically ill, but can go for years like this. Sherwin admits he wishes father would die. Is this wish bad? Irresponsible? Common under the circumstances?
78. Many become alienated from a sick parent, and do anything to escape, including changing name, religion, occupation, etc. Associate parent with oppression, superstition, bad upbringing, etc.
79. P 158. Camp Boiberik exemplities values of many immigrants, (not like Meyer). These were peope who had rejected religion and Zionism. Their faith was secular and political. Socialism or Communism, usuall with their own separate camps and instituions, One common denomator was commitment to Yiddish language.
80. P 159-161. At camp, 19 years old, entering senior year of college, he undergoes an “exploratory hedonism” What was that about? Major change from his previous life. “time of your life”
81. P 161-163 Sherwin is furious that his father wants him to come visit him in the hospital, even though he is getting better. Is fathers demand reasonable and responsible? Is Sherwins fury reasonable and responsible?
82. P 163 Sherwin has a recurrence of depression. Discuss. How is it manifest? loss of enthusiasm, loss of sense of pleasure, and irritability. Triggered by visit to father. Powerful trigger. His whole personality changes. This is a good description of what depression feels like “I lost the happy wonder”
83. P 164. Application to Med School I also came from a predom Jewish school; about 20 applied to Med School; 8 were accepted.
84. P 166 Why is he so eager to go to Yale? Fantasy, affluent America, free of Bronx, Yiddish accents, his father. Unattainable, therefore even more desirable.
85. P 167 Re Meyer and Rose’s reaction to him possibley going to Yale, he feels smothered by their love. How does that work?
86. P 169-171 Why did Meyer want to marry Rose?
87. P 173. Why is Sherwin depressed again? He is not only going to College, but leaving his father and aunt for the first time. Guilt, dramatic change in life circumstances, likely act as triggers.
88. P 176-178. What do you think about Sherwins reaction to learning that his father had tabes dorsalis, one of the forms of neurosyphilis? Does it change his attitude toward his father? He refers to “strong man robbed of his manhood” And in very dramatic fashion, he becomes aware of his own longing, of the mutual love that he and his father have for each other. And this knowledge (P 183) allows Sherwin to appreciate the “magnitude of his burden”.
89. P 182-183 Re father not knowing his diagnosis. One of the principles of bioethics is autonomy. This includes the right of everyone to make their own decisions, and that requires full disclosure by any physician of whatever is wrong with the patient. This runs counter to the principle of beneficence in which you do whatever is right for the patient. In the case of Meyer, he was not told his diagnosis. Most bioethicists would disagree with this. What do you think?
90. Treatment of syphilis. Prior to penicillin (about 1945), treatment was of little value. Used fever therapy in attempt to kill spirochetes (organisms that cause the disease). However, penicillin is very effective for primary syphilis, but has little or no effect on later tabes.
91. P 184. Talks about his father having lost. What is he referring to? He had given up fighting against his disease, finally accepting that his life was over, and he had two sons to show for it.
92. P 188-192. Sherwin’s first girl friend. Contrast her family with his family and effect that had on him, seeing a family where they all liked each other. Was this because the families were really different or because the individuals had no history of tragedy, depression, etc.
93. P 193-194 Sherwin realizes he will never totally separate from his father and home. Why Is this? Drenched in memories, Old emotional burden both a burden and a support.
94. P 197 Why did Sherwin pick surgery as a specialty? Influence of charismatic teacher, for him a combination of aesthetics and intellectual factors,
95. P 206-209 Sherwins final visit with his father. Finally they were at peace with each other. Why couldn’t Sherwin tell his father that he loved him?
96. Afterward; In what ways will Sherwin never be free of his father?
Labels:
Autonomy,
Beneficence,
Bioethics,
doctors,
Health Care,
Medical Humanities,
Rationing,
Sherwin Nuland
Tuesday, December 1, 2009
Course 1; 2009; Fall; Book 1; Wit
Author; Margaret Edson
Background
The play has multiple layers. Sophisticated, yet accessible to anyone.
Won many awards, including Pulitzer Prize.
This play, like all great literature, changes us in some way as a result of seeing or reading it.
Author
Margaret Edson has degrees in history and literature. She wrote Wit, her first play, in 1991. She incorporated her own experience into the play, including working for one year as a clerk in an oncology/AIDS department of the National Institute of Health, and watching the final illness and death of her brother from cancer. She currently teaches Kindergarten.
Outline of Story
The story is deceptively simple. It consists of the last hours (it actually covers eight months ) of Vivien Bearing, a professor of English with a special interest in the poet John Donne. Dr. Bearing is dying of metastatic ovarian cancer, advanced, not curable, and is hospitalized for chemotherapy.
The story is compressed into a few hours by using her recollections and flashbacks in which we see her in the classroom, both as teacher and as student, with her father, undergoing tests by various technicians, and being the subject at grand rounds. . She interacts with hospital staff including nurses, technicians, attending physicians, and residents. Most of the dialogue consists of the protagonist commenting on the events.
-------------------------------------------------edit
Through the course of the play Vivian assesses her own life through the intricacies of language, the use of wit, and the poetry of John Donne. Initially, she believes that she can control events, and is hyperrational and methodical, applying the approach she used as an academic superstar. Her life up to this point has been devoted to scholarly pursuits in which she preferred intellect to human relationship. She is without friends or family. Her personality is both powerful and prickly.
Watching the doctors treating her as an experimental object, and being interested in her primarily for their research, she becomes aware of the similarity to her own teaching and study. With disease progression and the onset of pain, along with the arrogance and insensitivity of some of the staff, she begins to question the values that have been a part of her. She evolves, finally understanding those values that make life worth living, recognizing that she prefers kindness to intellect.
Questions for Discussion
1. Comment on whether or not you liked the play, and why or why not?
2. Comment on any ethical issues that grabbed you.
3. What is the play about?
What makes life worth living; a age-old question with no real answer
Mortality - as a unifying experience
– vital importance of being in relationship
Importance of kindness (the play shows arrogance to make the point)
Importance of compassion (the play shows insensitivity to make the point)
What makes life worth living. Our lives are ours to celebrate or waste.
Is how we live our lives and interact with others more important than our
achievements (intellectual, professional, material)?
The play asks us all; what is most important in life, especially as that life comes
to an end.
4. The protagonist, Vivian Bearing, is getting experimental treatment
Is this ethical?
Is she an individual i.e. a human person, or an experimental subject?
Is it possible to be both?
Two ethical issues here
(A) Autonomy; Informed consent;
- For patient to freely choose, must be given all information that
is available;
- Is treatment voluntary?
e.g. of abuses; Tuskegee Syphilis experiments in US,
Nazi medical experiments
- is Vivien really given adequate information? Toward end of play, Susie implies that the doctors gave Vivien false information, and never really expected the treatment to cure her.
(B) Justice; Conflict of interest
Are doctors more interested in individual patient, or in research
protocol? This comes up in several settings, including when the
researchers ignore her or are insensitive, and in the decision to call a code
when she dies. The doctor has dual responsibilities which may be in
conflict. (Taking care of patient, with patient welfare being primary; or
advancing research goals, and having patient welfare come second)
5. What changes does Vivien undergo as a result of her terminal illness?
Her final illness allows her to focus on changing values. She finds that kindness
and compassion are preferable to intellect. This is a profound and fundamental
shift for her
6. Regarding her use of pain medicine at the end of life:
(A) Should there be a limit on the quantity and type of medicine?
Some say YES, use minimum amounts
Fear of addiction
A little pain is good for the soul
Some (including me) say NO
There is nothing noble about pain
Use whatever is needed to take away pain completely
(B) Who should be in control of amount of medicine, doctor or patient?
In the play, the nurse wants patient to decide, the doctor wants a fixed
dose, prescribed by doctor without patient input. .
What are disadvantages of doctor controlling;
With doctor controlling,
May give too little, with patient still having pain
May give too much, with patient not being awake and/or alert.
Why might doctor want to be in control of this?
Why does Dr. Kelekian want to do this?
high doses of morphine will hasten death
This is the socially acceptable form of euthanasia, and is widely
practiced.
Double effect; excess morphine will relieve pain, but will also hasten death.
If the primary intent is to relieve pain, then it is considered ethically OK
even if one knows it will hasten death.
6. Futility vs. Hope; In the play a DNR (Do not resuscitate) order is written for Vivien. (This is an opportunity to show a major medical foul-up)
DNR is in contrast to a situation in which the patient or surrogate wants
everything done if her heart or breathing stop.
How does one make the decision in favor of DNR? Many factors; e.g.
Quality of life; only patient can decide this
Underlying condition temporary and treatable, or not
Coexisting illnesses, e.g. dementia, kidney failure, etc
7. There is a kind of banality in illness and death, as seen by the house staff. A persons entire life, achievements, feelings, intellect, connections, loves, family, are all reduced by residents to a medical history. Is this to be expected? Is it good for staff? For patients? How can one avoid this reduction?
8. Jason uses the term “salvation anxiety” referring to John Donne. What does he mean? Is it a universal fear? On the one hand, a promise of salvation, cant face life without it, religion, etc. On other hand, intellect, concept of salvation “doesn’t stand up to scrutiny”.
9. RE “allegory of the soul. No matter where it hides, God will find it” P 80. Does
one need to be religious to appreciate this?
10. Vivian states that “once I did the teaching, now I am taught” What does she mean?
Symmetry; she is being studied much like a text,
Indicates a loss of power.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Extra questions if there is time.
What does Vivian’s opening monologue (P5-7) tell us about her as a person?
What does the author mean when she describes the play as not about doctors or about cancer, but about kindness?
Contrast the approach to medical care by Susie and by the doctors.
Re Professor Ashford’s visit as Vivian is dying. Is this real or a dream? What purpose does it serve?
P76; Jason; (referring to Donne); “the puzzle takes over. You’re not even trying to solve it anymore”. How does this apply to the medical research that Jason is involved in? The research has a life of its own that takes over, independent of its supposed goal
Death be not proud (see P 29). This line from Donne’s poetry is a recurring theme. What does it mean?
Why is the play called WIT; (see page 20)? Does Wit help with death?
Professor Ashford calls “The Runaway Bunny” “a little allegory of the soul”. (P 80) What does she mean?
The use of language. Vivien describes being asked “how are you?” while she is vomiting. An automatic question; the answer should be obvious. Why do they do this, and what is the effect? This is feigned solicitude, and is a sign of insensitivity.
Background
The play has multiple layers. Sophisticated, yet accessible to anyone.
Won many awards, including Pulitzer Prize.
This play, like all great literature, changes us in some way as a result of seeing or reading it.
Author
Margaret Edson has degrees in history and literature. She wrote Wit, her first play, in 1991. She incorporated her own experience into the play, including working for one year as a clerk in an oncology/AIDS department of the National Institute of Health, and watching the final illness and death of her brother from cancer. She currently teaches Kindergarten.
Outline of Story
The story is deceptively simple. It consists of the last hours (it actually covers eight months ) of Vivien Bearing, a professor of English with a special interest in the poet John Donne. Dr. Bearing is dying of metastatic ovarian cancer, advanced, not curable, and is hospitalized for chemotherapy.
The story is compressed into a few hours by using her recollections and flashbacks in which we see her in the classroom, both as teacher and as student, with her father, undergoing tests by various technicians, and being the subject at grand rounds. . She interacts with hospital staff including nurses, technicians, attending physicians, and residents. Most of the dialogue consists of the protagonist commenting on the events.
-------------------------------------------------edit
Through the course of the play Vivian assesses her own life through the intricacies of language, the use of wit, and the poetry of John Donne. Initially, she believes that she can control events, and is hyperrational and methodical, applying the approach she used as an academic superstar. Her life up to this point has been devoted to scholarly pursuits in which she preferred intellect to human relationship. She is without friends or family. Her personality is both powerful and prickly.
Watching the doctors treating her as an experimental object, and being interested in her primarily for their research, she becomes aware of the similarity to her own teaching and study. With disease progression and the onset of pain, along with the arrogance and insensitivity of some of the staff, she begins to question the values that have been a part of her. She evolves, finally understanding those values that make life worth living, recognizing that she prefers kindness to intellect.
Questions for Discussion
1. Comment on whether or not you liked the play, and why or why not?
2. Comment on any ethical issues that grabbed you.
3. What is the play about?
What makes life worth living; a age-old question with no real answer
Mortality - as a unifying experience
– vital importance of being in relationship
Importance of kindness (the play shows arrogance to make the point)
Importance of compassion (the play shows insensitivity to make the point)
What makes life worth living. Our lives are ours to celebrate or waste.
Is how we live our lives and interact with others more important than our
achievements (intellectual, professional, material)?
The play asks us all; what is most important in life, especially as that life comes
to an end.
4. The protagonist, Vivian Bearing, is getting experimental treatment
Is this ethical?
Is she an individual i.e. a human person, or an experimental subject?
Is it possible to be both?
Two ethical issues here
(A) Autonomy; Informed consent;
- For patient to freely choose, must be given all information that
is available;
- Is treatment voluntary?
e.g. of abuses; Tuskegee Syphilis experiments in US,
Nazi medical experiments
- is Vivien really given adequate information? Toward end of play, Susie implies that the doctors gave Vivien false information, and never really expected the treatment to cure her.
(B) Justice; Conflict of interest
Are doctors more interested in individual patient, or in research
protocol? This comes up in several settings, including when the
researchers ignore her or are insensitive, and in the decision to call a code
when she dies. The doctor has dual responsibilities which may be in
conflict. (Taking care of patient, with patient welfare being primary; or
advancing research goals, and having patient welfare come second)
5. What changes does Vivien undergo as a result of her terminal illness?
Her final illness allows her to focus on changing values. She finds that kindness
and compassion are preferable to intellect. This is a profound and fundamental
shift for her
6. Regarding her use of pain medicine at the end of life:
(A) Should there be a limit on the quantity and type of medicine?
Some say YES, use minimum amounts
Fear of addiction
A little pain is good for the soul
Some (including me) say NO
There is nothing noble about pain
Use whatever is needed to take away pain completely
(B) Who should be in control of amount of medicine, doctor or patient?
In the play, the nurse wants patient to decide, the doctor wants a fixed
dose, prescribed by doctor without patient input. .
What are disadvantages of doctor controlling;
With doctor controlling,
May give too little, with patient still having pain
May give too much, with patient not being awake and/or alert.
Why might doctor want to be in control of this?
Why does Dr. Kelekian want to do this?
high doses of morphine will hasten death
This is the socially acceptable form of euthanasia, and is widely
practiced.
Double effect; excess morphine will relieve pain, but will also hasten death.
If the primary intent is to relieve pain, then it is considered ethically OK
even if one knows it will hasten death.
6. Futility vs. Hope; In the play a DNR (Do not resuscitate) order is written for Vivien. (This is an opportunity to show a major medical foul-up)
DNR is in contrast to a situation in which the patient or surrogate wants
everything done if her heart or breathing stop.
How does one make the decision in favor of DNR? Many factors; e.g.
Quality of life; only patient can decide this
Underlying condition temporary and treatable, or not
Coexisting illnesses, e.g. dementia, kidney failure, etc
7. There is a kind of banality in illness and death, as seen by the house staff. A persons entire life, achievements, feelings, intellect, connections, loves, family, are all reduced by residents to a medical history. Is this to be expected? Is it good for staff? For patients? How can one avoid this reduction?
8. Jason uses the term “salvation anxiety” referring to John Donne. What does he mean? Is it a universal fear? On the one hand, a promise of salvation, cant face life without it, religion, etc. On other hand, intellect, concept of salvation “doesn’t stand up to scrutiny”.
9. RE “allegory of the soul. No matter where it hides, God will find it” P 80. Does
one need to be religious to appreciate this?
10. Vivian states that “once I did the teaching, now I am taught” What does she mean?
Symmetry; she is being studied much like a text,
Indicates a loss of power.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Extra questions if there is time.
What does Vivian’s opening monologue (P5-7) tell us about her as a person?
What does the author mean when she describes the play as not about doctors or about cancer, but about kindness?
Contrast the approach to medical care by Susie and by the doctors.
Re Professor Ashford’s visit as Vivian is dying. Is this real or a dream? What purpose does it serve?
P76; Jason; (referring to Donne); “the puzzle takes over. You’re not even trying to solve it anymore”. How does this apply to the medical research that Jason is involved in? The research has a life of its own that takes over, independent of its supposed goal
Death be not proud (see P 29). This line from Donne’s poetry is a recurring theme. What does it mean?
Why is the play called WIT; (see page 20)? Does Wit help with death?
Professor Ashford calls “The Runaway Bunny” “a little allegory of the soul”. (P 80) What does she mean?
The use of language. Vivien describes being asked “how are you?” while she is vomiting. An automatic question; the answer should be obvious. Why do they do this, and what is the effect? This is feigned solicitude, and is a sign of insensitivity.
Monday, November 30, 2009
Course 2, 2010 Winter. Introduction
We will be studying selected works of literature with a view to examining what they can teach us about medicine, bioethics, and applied philosophy, including such issues as the doctor-patient relationship, death and dying, conflicts of interest in medical care, clarification of our values, etc.
Lessons in the ethics of medicine occur all over, including daily papers and journals, news shows on TV, Television dramas, film, and literature.
We will be focusing on literature with a view to learning something about both bioethics and literature, and what they can teach us about ourselves and our values.
I invite readers to ask questions, and to suggest books, films, or TV programs that demonstrate ethical issues.
I have selected 4 books.
One Memoir; An Unquiet Mind, by Kay Redfield Jamison; Bipolar Affective Disorder
One short story collection, Chekhov's Doctors; A Colleciton of Chekhov's Medical Tales, Ed by Jack Coulehan.
One Non-fiction; The Spirit Catches You and You Fall Down, by Anne Fadiman,
One Fiction; Cutting for Stone, by Abraham Verghese.
Each book will reiterate a number of ethical dilemmas and issues.
Lessons in the ethics of medicine occur all over, including daily papers and journals, news shows on TV, Television dramas, film, and literature.
We will be focusing on literature with a view to learning something about both bioethics and literature, and what they can teach us about ourselves and our values.
I invite readers to ask questions, and to suggest books, films, or TV programs that demonstrate ethical issues.
I have selected 4 books.
One Memoir; An Unquiet Mind, by Kay Redfield Jamison; Bipolar Affective Disorder
One short story collection, Chekhov's Doctors; A Colleciton of Chekhov's Medical Tales, Ed by Jack Coulehan.
One Non-fiction; The Spirit Catches You and You Fall Down, by Anne Fadiman,
One Fiction; Cutting for Stone, by Abraham Verghese.
Each book will reiterate a number of ethical dilemmas and issues.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)